Comparative law global context by Werner F. Menski

By Werner F. Menski

Now in its moment variation, this textbook provides a severe rethinking of the learn of comparative legislations and felony thought in a globalising global, and proposes a brand new version. It highlights the inadequacies of present Western theoretical methods in comparative legislations, overseas legislation, criminal thought and jurisprudence, in particular for learning Asian and African legislation, arguing that they're too parochial and eurocentric to fulfill worldwide demanding situations. Menski argues for combining smooth common legislation theories with positivist and socio-legal traditions, construction an interactive, triangular idea of criminal pluralism. encouraged because the fourth significant method of felony concept, this version is utilized in analysing the historic and conceptual improvement of Hindu legislation, Muslim legislations, African legislation and chinese language legislation.

Show description

Read or Download Comparative law global context PDF

Similar comparative books

Comparative Survey of Securities Laws: A review of the securities and related laws of fourteen nations

The part on company legislation of the overseas Bar organization is drastically indebted to the Editor, J. Michael Robinson and to John Gauntlett, the Chairman of the Committee on concerns and buying and selling in Securities, and his Vice­ Chairmen, Blaise Pasztory, Robert Briner and the individuals of the Committee who've contributed, for his or her joint efforts in getting ready this ftrst booklet in their committee.

The Method and Culture of Comparative Law: Essays in Honour of Mark Van Hoecke

Know-how for the necessity to deepen the methodological foundations of criminal examine is simply contemporary. an analogous is right for comparative legislations, through nature a extra adventurous department of felony study, that's usually anything researchers easily do, at any time when they appear at international felony structures to reply to a number of of quite a number questions on legislations, even if those questions are doctrinal, fiscal, sociological, and so on.

COMECON Data 1990

This guide of statistical facts at the economies of jap Europe, together with Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union covers such issues as distribution and creation, international exchange and indebtedness, family finance, strength families and criteria of residing.

Additional resources for Comparative law global context

Example text

People have a right to resist human rights concepts imported by religious and secular missionaries who pretend knowledge of everything without having set foot into the areas in which they want to do missionary work. Hinz (2003a: 117) highlights that there is a need for what he calls the ‘soft human rights approach’, since traditional societies have the skills to react constructively to new challenges: One of the ways to which I would give priority, is to empower traditional communities and groups of stakeholders like traditional leaders consciously to judge the suitability of their own way of doing things in the context of the present enhancement of human rights.

All of these complex, major traditions thus achieve complexity because of their proven ability to hold together mutually inconsistent sub-traditions. They all involve a particular way of thinking, which has become explicit in some of them, though remaining implicit in others. It is a way of thinking which has been described as multivalent, as opposed to bivalent, because sub-traditions are not either right or wrong but may be right in different, multiple (inconsistent) ways. The traditions are hence multivalued .

11 Is law not supposed to be about certainty, clarity and well-formulated rules? From a conventional perspective, difference becomes an invitation for lawyers to unify, streamline and harmonise. But on what criteria should this be based? Accepting that the plurality of ‘law’ has no theoretical limits, it ‘becomes unproductive to consider the practical limitations of “law” in any given society, let alone in the world.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.34 of 5 – based on 24 votes